FAOK Study Cover
Report

Winning the FOAK challenge

What does it take to turn a pioneering bio-based plant into an industrial success? This study shares first-hand lessons from three European first-of-a-kind (FOAK) biorefineries run by UPM, Avantium and Fibenol.

First-of-a-kind plants are the bridge between a technology that works in the lab and an industry that works at scale. Yet a first plant is not proven once it is built: the decisive tests often come later, during commissioning, ramp-up and customer qualification.

Winning the First-of-a-Kind Challenge draws on structured interviews with UPM (Leuna, Germany), Avantium (Delfzijl, the Netherlands) and Fibenol (Imavere, Estonia), with each company reviewing and validating the findings. It shows how they managed finance, feedstock and offtake, and sets out four key lessons:

  • Financing must cover ramp-up, not just construction.
  • Begin with one controlled feedstock route before adding flexibility.
  • Turn customer interest into binding offtake.
  • Regulation must make sustainable value usable: for example through bio-based carbon recognition, credible claims, workable certification and demand measures such as mandates and public procurement.

The study offers a practical reference for developers, investors and policymakers. It also contributes to the debate on the 2028–2034 EU budget and on delivering the EU Bioeconomy Strategy.

Author: Melich Seefeldt (Via Solutis), on behalf of BIC.